How Ecommerce Brands Should Evaluate 3PL Performance in the First 90 Days

You just signed with a new 3PL. The contract is done, the inventory is transferred, and orders are starting to flow. Everything looks great on paper.

Then three months later, you're scrambling because your fulfillment accuracy is sitting at 92% (when you were promised 99.5%), shipping costs are 18% higher than projected, and you're spending half your day putting out fires with customer service tickets about late deliveries.

Sound familiar?

Here's the thing: most ecommerce brands wait too long to evaluate their 3PL performance. They give their fulfillment partner six months, maybe a year, before they start asking hard questions. By then, you've already lost revenue, burned through customer goodwill, and wasted time on a partnership that isn't working.

The first 90 days with a 3PL are critical. This is when you establish baseline expectations, catch red flags early, and set the tone for the entire partnership. Get it right, and you'll scale smoothly. Get it wrong, and you're looking at another painful migration in 12 months.

Let's break down exactly how to evaluate 3PL performance evaluation during those crucial first 90 days, what metrics actually matter, and how to know if your fulfillment partner can scale with you.

‍

Why the First 90 Days Matter More Than You Think

Most ecommerce operators treat the first three months with a new 3PL like a honeymoon period. Everyone's on their best behavior, communication is responsive, and performance looks solid. But this window is actually your best opportunity to stress test the relationship before you're locked in.

During the first 90 days with a 3PL, you're establishing patterns that will define your partnership for years. Your 3PL is learning your SKUs, understanding your peak patterns, and figuring out how to integrate with your systems. If they're cutting corners now or showing communication gaps when order volume is relatively low, imagine what happens when you 3x your volume during Black Friday.

Think about it this way: if your 3PL can't maintain 99%+ accuracy when they're fulfilling 500 orders a day, they're definitely not going to hit that mark at 2,000 orders a day. And if it takes them 48 hours to respond to a simple inventory question in Month 1, you're going to be waiting a week during Q4.

The early days are also when you have the most leverage. You haven't fully committed your inventory, you probably haven't sent all your SKUs yet, and switching costs are relatively low. After six months, you're deeply integrated into their systems, you've distributed inventory across multiple fulfillment centers, and the thought of migrating makes you want to crawl into bed and not come out.

‍

Setting Up for Success Before Day 1

Before we get into the metrics, let's talk about what needs to happen before your first order ships. Too many brands skip this step and then wonder why their 3PL performance evaluation reveals problems.

Lock in Your Service Level Agreements

Your SLA should spell out exactly what you expect, with real numbers attached. Not "fast fulfillment" but "95% of orders ship same day if received by 2pm EST." Not "high accuracy" but "99.5% order accuracy or credit on fulfillment fees." Get specific about:

• Order accuracy rates (aim for 99.5% minimum)
• Same day shipping cutoffs and fulfillment speed
• Inventory accuracy thresholds (99%+ is standard)
• Response times for support tickets (4 hours for urgent, 24 hours for standard)
• Credits or penalties when they miss targets

If your 3PL won't commit to specific numbers in writing, that's your first red flag.

Map Out Your Communication Cadence

Set up regular check ins from day one. Weekly calls for the first month, then bi weekly through Month 3. These aren't just status updates. Come prepared with specific questions about fulfillment times, error rates, and any issues you're seeing in customer feedback.

Create a shared dashboard or reporting template so you're both looking at the same numbers. Nothing kills a partnership faster than arguing about whether accuracy is 96% or 98% because you're calculating it differently.

Establish Your Baseline Metrics

You need to know where you started to measure improvement. Before you migrate, document your current performance:

• Average fulfillment cost per order
• Shipping costs by zone
• Order accuracy rate
• Average time from order to ship
• Inventory accuracy
• Customer complaints related to fulfillment

These become your benchmarks. Your new 3PL should match or beat these numbers, not make them worse.

‍

The 30-60-90 Day Framework for 3PL Performance Evaluation

Let's break down what you should be tracking and evaluating at each stage of your first 90 days with a 3PL.

Days 1-30: Establish the Baseline

The first month is all about watching how your 3PL handles the basics when they're still in onboarding mode. They're going to be extra attentive right now, so use this time to set high standards.

Order Accuracy: The Non Negotiable

This is your most critical metric, period. If customers are getting the wrong items, everything else doesn't matter. You should be tracking:

• Percentage of orders fulfilled accurately
• Types of errors (wrong item, wrong quantity, wrong address)
• How quickly errors are caught and resolved

Modern 3PLs should be running at 99.5% accuracy or better. If you're seeing accuracy below 98% in Month 1, that's a serious problem. Their warehouse management system should have built in checks during picking and packing. Barcode scanning at every step, weight verification, photo confirmation for custom orders.

One brand I talked to recently ignored a 96% accuracy rate in Month 1 because their account manager said they were "still learning the SKUs." By Month 4, they were at 94% and dealing with a customer service nightmare. Don't make that mistake.

Fulfillment Speed: Watch the Clock

Track how long it takes from when an order hits their system to when it ships. Break this down by:

• Orders received before cutoff vs after
• Standard orders vs customized orders
• Different product categories or SKU types

Most DTC brands should see same day fulfillment for orders received before 2pm or 3pm. If your 3PL is consistently taking 24-48 hours to pick and pack during a low volume period, that's a red flag. What happens when volume doubles?

Inventory Receiving: The Hidden Time Sink

Nobody talks enough about receiving times, but this can kill your cash flow. When you send inventory to your 3PL, how long until it's checked in, counted, and available to ship?

Best in class 3PLs receive and process inventory within 24-48 hours. If yours is taking 5-7 days to check in a pallet, you're going to have major problems during rapid growth phases when you need to restock quickly.

Track:

• Time from delivery to check in complete
• Inventory accuracy during receiving (are they counting correctly?)
• Damaged or missing items during transit

Communication Responsiveness

In Month 1, note how quickly your 3PL responds to questions and concerns. Create a simple log:

• Urgent issues (inventory issues, order problems): Should get response within 4 hours
• Standard questions (reporting, forecasting): Should get response within 24 hours
• Strategic discussions (scaling, new services): Should get scheduled within a week

If you're waiting 2-3 days for responses to urgent issues in Month 1, it's only going to get worse as you become a less "shiny" new client.

‍

Days 31-60: Stress Test the System

Month 2 is when you start pushing harder and seeing how they handle increased complexity.

Inventory Accuracy Under Pressure

Your inventory records should match physical inventory at least 99% of the time. Run cycle counts or spot checks on your top selling SKUs. Compare your system of record with what the 3PL is showing.

Discrepancies kill businesses. If you think you have 200 units but really have 20, you oversell and create a customer service disaster. If you think you have 20 but really have 200, you're paying for unnecessary rush reorders and missing sales.

Ask your 3PL:

• How often do they do cycle counts?
• What's their process when they find discrepancies?
• Can you request a specific SKU count whenever you want?

Cost Per Order: Watch the Invoice

By Month 2, you should have enough order volume to analyze your true cost per unit shipped. This includes:

• Pick and pack fees
• Storage costs
• Shipping costs by zone
• Any "surprise" fees (processing fees, special handling, peak season surcharges)

Compare this to what you were quoted and to your previous fulfillment costs. Some variance is normal, especially if your order mix differs from projections. But if costs are 15-20% higher than quoted without clear explanation, you need to have a serious conversation.

One thing to watch: zone optimization. A good 3PL with multiple fulfillment centers should be routing your inventory to reduce shipping costs. If most of your orders are shipping from Zone 5 or higher when you have West Coast customers, they're not doing their job.

Returns Processing: The Moment of Truth

Returns are where 3PLs show their true colors. During Month 2, deliberately process some returns and track:

• How long from return arrival to inspection
• Accuracy of return processing (are they restocking correctly or marking everything as damaged?)
• Communication about returned inventory
• Speed of credit or refund processing

Poor returns processing loses you money twice. First, you eat the shipping cost and lose the sale. Second, if they're not restocking perfectly good inventory, you're paying for new units you don't need.

Peak Preparation: Start the Conversation

Even if Q4 is months away, Month 2 is when you should start talking about how they handle peak season. Ask:

• What's their capacity plan for peak?
• Do they charge peak season surcharges? How much?
• What's their historical performance during peaks?
• Do they bring in temporary labor? How do they train them?

If they can't articulate a clear peak season strategy by Month 2, they don't have one. And you're going to pay for it.

‍

Days 61-90: Validate Scalability

By Month 3, the honeymoon is definitely over. Now you're seeing how they operate when you're just another client in their system.

Consistency Is Everything

Pull your metrics from Months 1 and 2 and compare. You should see:

• Order accuracy staying at 99%+ or improving
• Fulfillment speed remaining consistent or getting faster as they learn your SKUs
• Inventory accuracy holding steady
• Support response times maintaining initial standards

If performance is degrading in Month 3, that's a critical warning sign. They should be getting better as they learn your business, not worse.

Scalability Testing

If possible, run a flash sale or promotion during Month 3 to test how they handle volume spikes. Even a 2x increase in daily orders will reveal a lot about their systems and processes.

Watch for:

• Do fulfillment times slow down significantly?
• Does accuracy drop when they're busy?
• How's their communication during high volume periods?
• Can they scale labor quickly or do orders pile up?

Technology Integration: Is It Actually Working?

By Month 3, all your technology integrations should be running smoothly. This includes:

• Real time inventory syncing between your store and their system
• Automated shipping notifications
• Tracking information flowing correctly
• Returns processing updating inventory automatically

If you're still manually updating spreadsheets or dealing with sync issues in Month 3, something is fundamentally broken. Modern 3PLs should have robust APIs and integrations with all major ecommerce platforms. If they don't, you're going to spend hours every week on manual data entry.

The Final Check In: Strategic Alignment

Have a comprehensive review meeting at Day 90. This isn't just about numbers. You need to evaluate whether this partnership can support your long term growth.

Ask yourself:

• Do they understand your business and your customer?
• Are they proactively bringing solutions or just reacting to problems?
• Can they support your geographic expansion plans?
• Do they have the technology and services you'll need as you scale?
• Is working with them making your life easier or harder?

That last question matters more than you think. A good 3PL should feel like an extension of your team, not a vendor you're constantly fighting with.

‍

Red Flags That Mean You Should Cut Your Losses

Sometimes the best decision you can make is admitting the partnership isn't working and moving on before you're too deeply integrated. Here are the red flags that should make you seriously consider switching during or right after your first 90 days:

Accuracy Below 98% Consistently

If they can't maintain high accuracy during the easiest period of your partnership, it's not getting better. Cut your losses.

Communication Blackouts

If emails go unanswered for days or you can't get straight answers about basic questions, you're going to lose your mind when something actually goes wrong.

Surprise Fees Everywhere

Some 3PLs are great at hiding fees in contracts. If you're constantly getting charged for things you didn't expect and they can't clearly explain their fee structure, run.

"That's Not Possible" Culture

When you ask about customization, special projects, or scaling support and you keep hearing "we don't do that" or "that's not possible," they're not a growth partner. They're order takers.

Technology That Feels Like 2015

If you're logging into clunky systems, downloading CSV files manually, or waiting for daily batch updates instead of real time data, their technology is going to limit your growth.

Inventory Issues From Day One

If they lose inventory, consistently miscount during receiving, or can't explain discrepancies, this is not a company you can trust with your most valuable asset.

‍

Making Your 90 Day Evaluation Count

Here's what your actual 90 day review process should look like:

Build Your Scorecard

Create a simple scoring system for each key metric:

• Order accuracy: Target 99.5%+
• Fulfillment speed: Target same day for orders by cutoff
• Inventory accuracy: Target 99%+
• Support response: Urgent within 4 hours, standard within 24 hours
• Cost per order: Within 10% of quoted rates
• Technology performance: Zero sync issues, real time updates

Give each category a score from 1-5. Anything scoring below a 3 needs immediate attention. Multiple 2s or any 1s means you should seriously consider other options.

Document Everything

Keep detailed notes throughout the 90 days:

• Every email chain about problems
• Screenshots of inventory discrepancies
• Customer complaints related to fulfillment
• Response times to support tickets
• Invoice amounts vs quoted pricing

You're building either a case for continuing the partnership or evidence for why you need to switch. Either way, documentation matters.

Have the Hard Conversation

At Day 90, schedule a performance review meeting and be direct. Don't sugarcoat issues or accept vague promises about "working on it." You need specific action plans with timelines.

If there are problems, give them 30 days to fix them with clear milestones. Then do another review at Day 120. If things haven't materially improved, start your search for a new partner.

Plan Your Exit Strategy

Even if things are going well, know what your exit strategy would look like. How much notice do you need to give? What are the termination fees? How long would a migration take?

Having this information ready gives you negotiating power and peace of mind. You're not trapped.

‍

What Good 3PL Performance Actually Looks Like

Let's talk about what success looks like so you have realistic expectations.

Best in class 3PLs consistently deliver:

• 99.5%+ order accuracy
• Same day fulfillment for orders received before cutoff
• 99%+ inventory accuracy
• Under 4 hour response time for urgent issues
• Transparent, predictable pricing with no surprise fees
• Proactive communication about potential issues
• Real time inventory and order data
• Geographic distribution options that actually reduce shipping costs

They should also be bringing ideas to the table. A good 3PL partner will suggest ways to reduce costs, improve packaging, optimize inventory distribution, or enhance the customer experience. If the relationship is purely transactional (you send orders, they ship boxes), you're not getting the full value.

‍

The Bottom Line

Your first 90 days with a 3PL will tell you everything you need to know about whether this partnership can support your growth. Don't waste them.

Track the metrics that matter. Set high standards from day one. Have hard conversations when performance slips. And don't fall for the sunk cost fallacy if things aren't working.

The right 3PL should make your life easier, not harder. They should be a competitive advantage, not a constant source of stress. If you're spending more time managing your 3PL than growing your business, something is wrong.

Use these first 90 days to figure out if you've found a real partner or just another vendor. Your business growth depends on it.

Because here's what I know after talking to hundreds of ecommerce operators: the brands that scale successfully aren't necessarily the ones with the best products or the biggest marketing budgets. They're the ones who nail their fulfillment operations early and build partnerships with 3PLs who can actually execute.

Don't settle for mediocre fulfillment. Your customers won't, and neither should you.

‍

Frequently Asked Questions About 3PL Performance Evaluation

What metrics should I track during the first 90 days with a 3PL?

The most critical metrics to track during your first 90 days with a 3PL include order accuracy (target 99.5% or higher), fulfillment speed (same day shipping for orders received before cutoff), inventory accuracy (99%+ match between records and physical inventory), cost per unit shipped, and support response times. You should also monitor inventory receiving times (24-48 hours is standard), returns processing efficiency, and technology integration performance. Create a baseline during Month 1, stress test during Month 2, and validate consistency during Month 3. Track these metrics weekly and document any patterns or recurring issues that could indicate larger operational problems.

‍

How do I know if my 3PL is performing well or poorly in the first 90 days?

A well performing 3PL maintains 99.5% or higher order accuracy, ships orders same day when received before cutoff, responds to urgent issues within 4 hours, and keeps costs within 10% of quoted rates. Red flags include accuracy below 98%, fulfillment delays of 24-48 hours during low volume periods, communication blackouts lasting multiple days, surprise fees not outlined in your contract, and inventory discrepancies from day one. If performance degrades between Month 1 and Month 3 rather than improving as they learn your business, that's a critical warning sign. Good 3PLs get better over time, not worse.

‍

When should I consider switching 3PLs after the first 90 days?

Consider switching 3PLs if you see consistent order accuracy below 98%, repeated communication failures where urgent issues go unanswered for days, costs that are 15-20% higher than quoted without clear justification, or an inability to scale during even modest volume increases. Other deal breakers include persistent inventory count discrepancies, technology that requires manual workarounds or daily CSV downloads, and a "that's not possible" response to reasonable customization requests. The first 90 days offer the lowest switching costs, so if you're seeing multiple red flags by Day 90 and the 3PL can't provide a concrete action plan with measurable improvements within 30 days, start evaluating alternatives.

‍

What questions should I ask my 3PL during the 90 day evaluation period?

During your first 90 days, ask specific operational questions rather than accepting general assurances. Key questions include: What's your exact process for cycle counts and how often do you perform them? How do you handle inventory discrepancies when they're discovered? What's your peak season capacity plan and historical performance data? Can I request SKU counts on demand? What's your process for training temporary labor during high volume periods? How are returns inspected and restocked? What integrations do you support natively vs requiring custom development? Request detailed answers with specific numbers, timelines, and examples rather than vague promises about "working to improve" or "industry leading performance."

‍

How can I set up a successful 3PL partnership from day one?

Set up a successful 3PL partnership by establishing clear Service Level Agreements with specific, measurable targets before your first order ships. Document baseline metrics from your current fulfillment operation so you can measure improvement. Schedule regular check ins (weekly in Month 1, bi weekly through Month 3) with prepared agendas covering specific performance questions. Create a shared reporting dashboard so both parties are looking at the same data and calculating metrics consistently. Build a simple scorecard to track order accuracy, fulfillment speed, inventory accuracy, response times, and costs against targets. Most importantly, address issues immediately rather than waiting for quarterly reviews. The patterns you establish in the first 30 days will define the partnership for years, so set high standards from the beginning.