How to Build a Fulfillment Budget for the Next 12 Months

It's Q4. Your orders just tripled. Your 3PL is sending invoices you don't recognize. Your shipping costs are up 40% from last year and you have no idea why. Sound familiar?

Here's the hard truth most ecommerce operators don't want to hear: you didn't have a fulfillment budget. You had a vague number in your head and a hope that things would work out.

They rarely do.

Fulfillment budget planning isn't glamorous. It doesn't drive revenue the way a killer ad campaign does. But it's the thing that determines whether scaling your brand actually makes you money or just makes you busier. For DTC brands doing $500K to $10M in revenue, poor ecommerce logistics budgeting is one of the top reasons margins quietly collapse even as topline revenue grows.

So let's fix that.

‍

Why Most Ecommerce Brands Budget Fulfillment Wrong

Most brands approach fulfillment costs the way they approach returns: reactively. They look at last month's 3PL invoice, shrug, and add 10% for next year. That's not a budget. That's a guess wearing a spreadsheet.

The problem is that fulfillment is dynamic. Your costs per order don't stay flat. They shift based on your SKU count, your average order value, your carrier mix, your return rate, your packaging decisions, and a dozen other variables that compound over 12 months.

Here's what most brands get wrong:

They only budget for what they can see (pick and pack fees, shipping labels) and completely ignore the hidden cost drivers, storage fees that spike when inventory sits too long, dimensional weight charges eating into margins on bulky SKUs, zone 8 shipments that cost 2x what a zone 4 would. Most DTC brands see a 15 to 25% reduction in their per-order shipping costs just by auditing their zone distribution and adjusting their inventory placement strategy. That's real money.

They also don't account for seasonality properly. Your average monthly order volume is useless for budgeting purposes if 40% of your annual orders happen between November and January. You need a month-by-month model that reflects actual demand patterns, not a simple annual average divided by 12.

‍

The 5 Cost Buckets Every Fulfillment Budget Needs

Before you can build a credible 12-month ecommerce logistics budget, you need to understand the actual cost buckets. Miss one of these and your budget will be off, sometimes significantly.

1. Receiving and Storage

Every pallet that hits your 3PL's dock costs money. Receiving fees vary widely (some 3PLs charge per pallet, some per SKU, some per hour), and storage fees compound every month your inventory sits. If you're ordering too far in advance or your inventory velocity is slow, storage alone can quietly destroy a product's margin.

Budget tip: Calculate your average inventory turnover per SKU and build storage costs based on realistic dwell time, not ideal dwell time. If your supplements sit 45 days on average before shipping, budget for 45 days of storage, not 30.

‍

2. Pick, Pack, and Kitting

This is the most visible line on your 3PL invoice and, ironically, where most brands stop their analysis. Pick and pack fees are relatively predictable once you know your order volume and SKU complexity. Where it gets expensive fast is kitting, if you're running subscription boxes, bundled offers, or promotional SKUs, your per-order labor costs can be 2 to 3x a standard single-item order.

Map out any kitting or assembly work you're planning for the year and get line-item quotes. Don't assume it's covered in your base pick fee.

‍

3. Outbound Shipping

This is typically your single largest fulfillment cost, often 50 to 70% of total fulfillment spend for physical goods brands. And it's the most variable.

Your outbound shipping budget needs to account for: carrier rate changes (both UPS and FedEx have raised rates every January for years running), your dimensional weight profile, your zone distribution, and your service level mix. If you're offering free 2-day shipping to compete with Amazon, that's a different cost structure than standard ground.

Build your outbound shipping model around your actual order data. Pull your last 12 months of shipments, segment by weight break and zone, and calculate your blended cost per order. Then apply anticipated carrier rate increases (budget at least 5 to 8% annually) and project forward.

‍

4. Returns Processing

Ecommerce return rates average 20 to 30% across most product categories. Apparel runs higher (sometimes 40%+). Every return has a cost: inbound shipping, receiving at the fulfillment center, inspection, restock or disposal. Most brands either undercount returns in their fulfillment budget or treat them as a separate marketing/customer service problem.

They're not. They're a fulfillment cost. Build them in.

‍

5. Technology and Integration Fees

Your WMS, your Shopify or BigCommerce integration, your order management system, any EDI or retail compliance work — these are real costs that belong in your fulfillment budget. They're often fixed or semi-fixed, which makes them easy to project, but easy to forget.

‍

Building the Actual 12-Month Model

Here's a framework you can actually use. It's not complicated. The discipline is in filling it with real numbers instead of round guesses.

Step 1: Anchor to your demand forecast

Start with a month-by-month order volume projection. If you're on Shopify, pull your order history and look at the seasonal index — what percentage of annual orders fell in each month historically? Apply that pattern to your projected annual volume. If you're planning a big launch or promotion, layer that in explicitly.

‍

Step 2: Calculate your cost-per-order baseline

Take your actual fulfillment spend from the last 12 months (every invoice, every carrier charge) and divide by total orders shipped. That's your blended cost per order. Break it down by the five buckets above so you know what's driving it.

‍

Step 3: Apply rate changes and volume adjustments

Carrier rates go up January 1. If you're switching carriers or renegotiating your 3PL contract, model those changes explicitly. If your order volume is growing significantly, check whether your current fulfillment infrastructure can handle it without adding cost per order (most 3PLs have volume tiers).

‍

Step 4: Build in a variance buffer

No fulfillment budget survives first contact with peak season perfectly intact. Build in a 10 to 15% variance buffer for Q4 specifically — for unplanned surcharges, expedited shipping to rescue late orders, additional labor fees during peak, and the inevitable "we didn't see that coming" charge on your December invoice.

‍

Step 5: Review monthly, not quarterly

A 12-month fulfillment budget is a living document. Set a monthly review cadence where you compare actuals to budget, identify variances over 5%, and understand why they happened. This is how you get better at forecasting each year — and how you catch cost creep before it compounds.

‍

The Conversation You Need to Have With Your 3PL

If you're working with a 3PL, your fulfillment budget planning process has to include them. Not as a vendor you hand a spreadsheet to, but as an operational partner who helps you understand where your costs are coming from.

Ask your 3PL for a cost-per-order breakdown across all billable activities. Ask them what your storage utilization looks like month over month. Ask them what their carrier rate adjustment looks like for next year. Ask whether there are structural changes to your packaging or SKU mix that could reduce your per-order cost.

A good 3PL will have answers. If they can't tell you why your costs went up 20% last quarter, that's a problem, not just for your budget, but for your whole relationship.

‍

What a Realistic Fulfillment Budget Actually Looks Like

For a DTC brand shipping 5,000 orders per month with an average order weight of 1.5 lbs and a mixed zone distribution, a realistic fully loaded cost per order (including storage, pick and pack, outbound shipping, and returns processing) typically runs $8 to $14 depending on carrier mix and 3PL location footprint.

Scale that across your annual order volume, apply your seasonal curve, add your tech stack fees, and you have the skeleton of a real ecommerce logistics budget.

That's not a magic number. Your business will be different based on your product category, your 3PL's pricing structure, and your service level commitments. The point is to build the model around your actual data — not industry averages, not your competitor's cost structure, and definitely not the number you used last year plus 10%.

‍

The Bottom Line

Fulfillment budget planning isn't just a finance exercise. It's one of the highest-leverage operational decisions you'll make this year. Brands that build accurate, detailed fulfillment budgets catch cost increases early, negotiate better 3PL contracts, make smarter inventory decisions, and don't get blindsided by a December invoice that wrecks their Q4 margins.

The brands that skip it spend the first three months of every year trying to figure out what happened.

Start with your actual cost data. Build month by month. Review it monthly. And treat your fulfillment budget like what it actually is: the financial foundation of your entire operations strategy.

Your margins depend on it.

‍

Frequently Asked Questions

What should be included in a fulfillment budget?

‍A complete fulfillment budget covers five core cost buckets: receiving and storage, pick and pack fees, outbound shipping, returns processing, and technology or integration fees. Most brands undercount by only tracking what shows up on their 3PL invoice and missing the hidden cost drivers like dimensional weight charges and long-term storage fees.

‍

How do I calculate my cost per order for fulfillment?

‍Take your total fulfillment spend over the last 12 months — every 3PL invoice, every carrier charge — and divide by total orders shipped. That's your blended cost per order. From there, break it down by cost bucket so you know exactly what's driving it.

‍

How much should ecommerce fulfillment cost per order?

‍For most DTC brands, a fully loaded cost per order (storage, pick and pack, outbound shipping, and returns) typically runs $8 to $14 depending on product weight, carrier mix, and 3PL location. If you're consistently above that range, a fulfillment audit is worth prioritizing.

‍

When should I review my fulfillment budget?

‍Monthly. A 12-month fulfillment budget is a living document, not a set-it-and-forget-it spreadsheet. Monthly reviews let you catch cost variances early, before they compound into a margin problem by Q4.

‍

How do I reduce fulfillment costs without switching 3PLs?

‍Start with your zone distribution and packaging. Most brands see meaningful savings just by auditing where their orders are shipping and adjusting inventory placement to reduce high-zone shipments. Right-sizing your packaging to avoid dimensional weight penalties is the other quick win that doesn't require changing any operational relationships.